In a democratic society, should employees get to vote for their supervisors? Why or why not?
Here is the scenario. A company has a supervisor job opening. HR posts the job requirements. A number of respondents put in their applications. HR reviews all applications, and of qualified applicants, posts the qualifications where employees can read and compare. Then on the appointed day, the employees vote to fill the position. We elect government officials and call that freedom and a basic right. Should that extend to the work place? What is wrong or right with this scenario? Good point, Dante.
Asked By: Captain Klepto - 5/27/2010
Best Answer - Chosen by Asker
Actually Baker Hughes uses something very similar, it is modeled off of the Harley Davidson business model. They hire you on temp and when it comes time to put you on permanently the members of your team get a vote. Also, all supervisors are reviewed by their people at review time.
Answered By: itsamini1 - 5/27/2010
Additional Answers (13)
thats not politics thats a JOB!
Answered By: Rick Astley - 5/27/2010
There is no Democracy in private business...
Answered By: Blueprint for Change - 5/27/2010
Maybe you should offer it as a suggestion to your employer. Don't hold your breath as far as your employer implementing it though.
Answered By: Will - 5/27/2010
A private company has a owner not a society. Comrade!
Answered By: Dio - 5/27/2010
Business isn't a democracy.
Answered By: chuck_junior - 5/27/2010
Answered By: Destructive Politics The Book - 5/27/2010
You are confusing GOVERNMENT with SOCIETY. They are different. But, as to your question, in some scenarios, that is exactly what happens. Take a corporation for example. Every year, there is a shareholder meeting where the shareholders ELECT the Board of Directors.
Answered By: Dante - 5/27/2010
Sure, and children should vote on their parents.
Answered By: Shovel Ready - 5/27/2010
Well since I put up all of the capital and assume all of the risk you have absolutely no say in who your supervisor will be - when you start your own company and assume all of the risk you can do whatever you would like
Answered By: Mr. Blutarsky 0.0 - 5/27/2010
Not in the private sector, no. If my employees got to pick their own supervisor, they would pick a lax one with no standards. Meritocracy would be replaced with corruption and cronyism.
Answered By: Tommy B - 5/27/2010
Whilst we live in a politically democratic society, we live in a capitalist society. Voting for ones boss would not make economic sense, as the popular people would get in, rather than those who perhaps produce the best results. Also, without elections every few years, how would you get rid of someone who was rubbish... More
Answered By: Kit Fang - 5/27/2010
Promotions are for those that achieve and play the game. It would never work to vote for he who could fire you.
Answered By: Patrick W - 5/27/2010
Well since you're drawing parallels with the way we elect our government perhaps you should carry it further. People get elected based on promises they often have no intentions of keeping or on their personal popularity. Not a good recipe for success in the workplace. A popular supervisor is not always the most... More
Answered By: Mike S - 5/27/2010
Over 483 Local Jobs Now Hiring In Your Area. $18-$87/Hr - Apply Today!
Legitimate Survey for Cash.Extra Money for You,Join Here!
Find All Jobs Hiring in Your Area. Hiring Immediately - Apply Today!
Shop Online or Sign Up To Sell AVON & Earn Fast Cash Today!
Other Career Questions
Do most mechanical engineering jobs offer job security?
What is your current job? Why did you choose this job? What do you enjoy about your job? What do you dislike about your job? What would be your perfect job? Would you rather have this j...
Where are the jobs? Is productivity and globalization creating a permanent “recession” of jobs? My main issue is I am doing a paper for school and have no idea where to begin. I was hoping suggestions...
Content is not owned or controlled by Monster. Any content concerns should be addressed with Yahoo!
Yahoo! Does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any Yahoo! Answers content. Yahoo! Disclaimer.
Best-Paying Work-from-Home Jobs
It’s easier than ever to work from home. Of course, not every job is a mobile job, and some companies aren’t interested in having their employees work from home.
2013 Marketing Jobs Outlook
The US may be facing another year of anemic hiring overall, but that won't be the case in the high-orbit world of multichannel, digital media marketing.
2013 Engineering Jobs Outlook
Engineers will find job opportunities in select disciplines in 2013, with candidates who are all-around, client-oriented businesspeople in demand.
Best-Paying Jobs by Major
What could you earn with a particular four-year degree? Find out by checking out this list of the top-paying jobs for 20 of the most common majors.
Eight High-Paying, Secure Jobs
Want to earn a good salary and enjoy a measure of job security as well? Check out these well-paying jobs on tap for fast growth in the coming years.